The main ways a DUI case can be challenged in California target the evidence behind the charge: the reason for the stop, how a checkpoint was run, roadside tests, Title 17 breath and blood procedures, test timing, statements, video and the officer's observations. Each challenge depends on specific records, and none guarantees a result.
Our San Diego DUI defense lawyer page lists the areas we review, and our article on whether a lawyer can get a DUI dropped covers dismissal in general. You don't need to read the 10 points below in order. If the problem is a breath or blood result, start at point 5. If you're worried about your license, the DMV deadline is covered near the end.
What does it mean to challenge a DUI case?
Challenging a DUI case means asking whether each piece of evidence was gathered and handled the way the law requires. Vehicle Code Section 23152 makes it unlawful to drive under the influence of alcohol (subdivision (a)) or with a blood alcohol level of 0.08% or more (subdivision (b)), and the 10 points below target the evidence for each. For an unlawful stop or search, the main tool is a motion to suppress under Penal Code Section 1538.5, which lets a defendant argue that a warrantless search or seizure was unreasonable.
Can the traffic stop or checkpoint be challenged?
Yes. If the stop was unlawful, evidence that came from it may be suppressed.
1. The legal reason for the stop
An officer generally needs reasonable suspicion of a violation or crime to stop a car, as our guide to traffic stop rules in San Diego explains. Since January 1, 2024, Vehicle Code Section 2806.5 has also required officers to state the reason for a stop before questioning the driver about a violation or investigation, and to document that reason on any citation or report, with a narrow exception for imminent threats.
This challenge depends on the report, the citation, dispatch records and the first minutes of video. If the stated reason, the written reason and the driving on camera don't match, the defense can raise that gap.
2. How the checkpoint was run
A sobriety checkpoint stops drivers without individual suspicion. In Ingersoll v. Palmer (1987) 43 Cal.3d 1321, the California Supreme Court upheld checkpoints that operate within limits. The factors it described include whether supervisors chose the site and procedures, drivers were selected by a neutral formula, the site was safe and clearly official, each stop was brief, and the checkpoint was publicized in advance.
To test a checkpoint, the defense asks for the agency's operations plan, supervisor approvals, staffing logs and any public announcement.
Can field sobriety and roadside breath tests be challenged?
Yes. How the officer gave these tests under the conditions at the scene is open to question, and so is what the officer told you about the PAS test.
3. Field sobriety test instructions and conditions
Tests such as the walk-and-turn and the one-leg stand ask a nervous driver to follow detailed instructions on a roadside. The defense compares the officer's account with how each test was actually explained and scored.
The officer's notes are one record. Video is the other, because it shows the surface, slope, lighting and footwear.
4. The roadside PAS test and the refusal advisement
Under Vehicle Code Section 23612(h), the handheld preliminary alcohol screening (PAS) test is a field sobriety test. Section 23612(i) requires the officer to tell you that the PAS test doesn't satisfy your duty to take a chemical test after arrest, and that you have the right to refuse it. Drivers under 21 and drivers on probation for a DUI are the exception: refusing or failing to complete the PAS test can suspend their license (Vehicle Code Sections 13388 and 13389). The post-arrest breath or blood test is different: refusing that one carries penalties, and Section 23612(a)(1)(D) requires a warning saying so.
Body-camera audio and the report show whether the advisement was given. If it is missing, the defense can question the weight of the PAS result.
Can breath and blood test results be challenged?
Yes. California's Title 17 regulations set procedures for breath and blood alcohol testing, and a departure from them is grounds for a challenge.
5. Breath instrument accuracy checks and the 15-minute wait
Title 17, Section 1221.2 of the California Code of Regulations requires breath instruments to be checked against reference samples at least every 10 days or every 150 subjects, whichever comes sooner. It also requires two separate breath samples that differ by no more than 0.02 grams per 210 liters, run by a trained operator. Section 1221.1 adds a 15-minute wait before collection, during which the person must not drink, eat, smoke, vomit or regurgitate.
That means checking the instrument's accuracy and maintenance logs, the operator's training record, the printout of both samples and video of the wait.
6. Blood draw, storage and chain of custody
Title 17, Section 1219.1 requires blood to be drawn by venipuncture, bars cleaning the skin with alcohol or another volatile organic disinfectant, and requires the sample to be mixed with an anticoagulant and a preservative. The remaining sample must be kept for one year after collection, and a defendant can request a portion for independent testing if enough remains.
Here the defense looks at the kit labels, who drew the blood and when, the evidence log tracking every transfer, and the lab worksheets. A break in that chain, or a retest that doesn't match, can undermine the result.
7. Time of driving versus time of the test
Under Vehicle Code Section 23152(b), a chemical test of 0.08% or more taken within three hours of driving creates a presumption that the level was 0.08% or more while driving. The presumption is rebuttable. When the test came more than three hours after driving, the presumption doesn't apply, and the prosecution has to connect the result to the driving another way.
Everything depends on exact times for the dispatch entry, the stop, the arrest, and the breath printout or blood draw.
Can statements, video and the arrest itself be challenged?
Yes. Anything you said is evidence, and it can be tested along with the recordings and the officer's reading of your behavior.
8. Statements and Miranda warnings
Statements taken during custodial interrogation without Miranda warnings or a valid waiver may be excluded at trial. In a DUI case, the issue can turn on when you were in custody compared with when a question like "How much have you had to drink?" was asked.
The time of arrest, the body-camera audio and the report show whether a Miranda argument has force. Excluding a statement doesn't remove the test results, so this challenge works alongside the others.
9. Body-camera and dash-camera video, including what's missing
Penal Code Section 1054.1 requires the prosecution to disclose defendants' statements, relevant real evidence and any exculpatory evidence. The defense uses that duty to obtain body-camera and dash-camera recordings and compare them with the report, line by line. Missing footage matters too. A camera that wasn't switched on, or a recording that starts after the field sobriety tests, is an issue the defense can raise with the court.
10. Medical conditions or other explanations
Officers commonly report red eyes, slurred speech and unsteady balance. Those are interpretations. An old injury can affect balance, and a medical condition, fatigue or a language barrier can change how someone speaks or follows instructions.
Medical records, work schedules and witness statements can back up another explanation, and the video may show steadier movement than the report describes.
What happens if a challenge works?
It depends on what the challenge removes. If a court suppresses evidence, the prosecution has to decide whether it can go forward without it. Sometimes the result is a dismissal. Other cases end in a plea to reckless driving, where Vehicle Code Section 23103.5 requires the prosecutor to state on the record whether alcohol or drugs were involved. That "wet reckless" can count as a prior if there's a later DUI. And some challenges fail. No challenge guarantees any outcome.
Is the DMV hearing a separate fight?
Yes. The DMV's Administrative Per Se (APS) license action runs separately from the court case, and the California DMV says its hearing decision is independent of any criminal charge or decision (California DMV, Driving Under the Influence, as of October 2026). You have 10 days from receiving the suspension or revocation order to request a hearing, and Vehicle Code Section 13558 says the request alone doesn't stop the suspension. Our San Diego DUI defense lawyer page explains the hearing in more detail.
This article is general information, not legal advice for your situation, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Frequently asked questions
Can I challenge a DUI if I failed the breath test?
Yes. A failed breath test is one piece of evidence. It can be questioned if the instrument missed its Title 17 accuracy checks, the two samples differed by more than 0.02 grams per 210 liters, the 15-minute wait wasn't followed, or the test came more than three hours after driving. Whether any of those issues exists depends on the device records and video.
Is refusing the roadside breath test the same as refusing a chemical test?
Not for most adult drivers. The roadside PAS test is a field sobriety test, and officers must tell you that you can refuse it. Drivers under 21 and drivers on DUI probation are different: refusing the PAS test can suspend their license. Refusing the breath or blood test after a lawful DUI arrest carries separate penalties under Vehicle Code Section 23612, including a license suspension or revocation.
How long is a DUI blood sample kept in California?
Title 17, Section 1219.1 requires the remaining portion of a DUI blood sample to be kept for one year after collection. During that year, a defendant can request a portion for independent testing, as long as enough of the sample remains. A defense attorney can make that request and arrange a separate lab retest.
How soon should I talk to a lawyer about challenging a DUI?
As soon as you can, mainly because of the DMV deadline. You have 10 days from receiving the suspension or revocation order to request a DMV hearing. Early contact also gives an attorney time to request records such as body-camera video, breath instrument logs and blood-handling records.
How we can help
At Flores Legal Allies, attorney Andrew Flores defends people charged with DUI in San Diego and Los Angeles. If you have a DMV suspension or revocation order, the 10-day window to request a hearing doesn't wait for the court case, so we help you make that request and prepare for the hearing. For the court case, we go through the evidence one record at a time: we request the report, the video, the breath or blood records and the timeline from stop to test, then check each of the 10 points above against your facts and tell you plainly which ones look worth raising and which don't. Through all of it, we listen first, because a DUI arrest is stressful and you should understand what's happening before you decide anything.
Learn more about our San Diego DUI defense lawyer services, or call (619) 356-1556 to request a free 30-minute consultation.